Meaning
Measured against the price paid by outside investors, the valuation of common stock often creates a specific gap. A fair market value discrepancy often arises when a company issues stock options at a low price while raising funds at a much higher price. Tax authorities look for these gaps to identify underpaid taxes.
The discrepancy disappears when a market price is set by a public exchange.
Valuation Gap
Private companies use independent appraisals to set the price for employee stock grants. If this price is much lower than the price paid by venture capitalists, a fair market value discrepancy exists. This gap reflects the lack of liquidity and the different rights of common and preferred shares.
Tax Implication
Revenue services treat the difference in price as taxable income for the recipient. If the fair market value discrepancy is too wide, the company may face penalties or forced adjustments. Practitioners must ensure that their appraisals are defensible and current to avoid these outcomes.
This prevents unexpected bills for the team. The burden of proof lies with the taxpayer.
Audit Exposure
Regular reviews by outside firms help manage the risks of mispricing. A large fair market value discrepancy is a flag for auditors during a sale or public offering. The company must provide evidence that the lower price was justified by the facts at the time.
This documentation is essential for a clean exit.