Meaning
Corporate governance failures occur when the majority or controlling shareholders of a close corporation abuse their power to freeze out minority owners. This behavior, known as minority shareholder oppression, typically involves squeezing the minority out of corporate decision-making and denying them a return on their investment. Controlling shareholders achieve this by terminating the minority shareholder’s employment, withholding dividends, and denying access to corporate records.
These actions strip the minority shares of their economic value since there is no public market where they can be sold.
Oppressive Tactic
Majority owners employ several methods to isolate and pressure minority shareholders who have fallen out of favor. A common strategy involves terminating the minority owner’s employment with the firm, which cut off their primary source of income if the company pays no dividends. The majority shareholders then increase their own salaries and bonuses, effectively distributing corporate profits only to themselves.
This leaves the minority owner with taxable corporate income but no cash to pay the tax liability.
Legal Remedy
Oppressed shareholders can seek relief from the courts to protect their economic interests. Available remedies include ordering the majority to buy out the minority’s shares at fair value or, in extreme cases of deadlock, ordering the dissolution of the corporation. The court evaluates whether the majority has breached its fiduciary duty of loyalty and fair dealing to the minority.
Business Impact
Internal legal battles disrupt daily operations and damage relationships with clients and suppliers. The business must divert cash flow and executive focus toward defense costs and litigation, which hinders long-term growth.