Meaning
Informal commitments to provide shares to employees or advisors create potential legal and financial liabilities for a venture. An unrecorded equity promise exists when a founder offers ownership through verbal agreement, email, chat logs or text message without formalizing it in a board-approved contract. These commitments often remain dormant until the company achieves success or prepares for a sale.
The liability associated with the promise remains until it is either converted into a legal grant or formally released by the claimant.
Shadow Obligation
Early team members may rely on a founder’s word as a reason to work for lower wages. An unrecorded equity promise functions as a covert contract that eventually demands a resolution. When the time comes to sell the company, these shadow obligations can derail the transaction.
Hidden Liability
Due diligence by investors often uncovers these informal agreements through a review of historical communications. An unrecorded equity promise can force a company to issue shares at a low price when the current value is much higher. This creates a tax problem for the recipient and a dilution problem for the existing shareholders.
The board of directors may be forced to ratify these past promises to avoid a lawsuit that would prevent a funding round from closing.
Contractual Uncertainty
Proving the existence of a verbal agreement requires evidence of a meeting of the minds and an exchange of value. The lack of a formal document makes the terms of an unrecorded equity promise difficult to enforce or defend. Resolution of these disputes usually results in a cash payment or a compromise equity grant that satisfies the claimant enough to prevent further legal action.